Passive Transit Signal Priority on Local Arterials: Model Formulation and Strategy Selection
Yongjie Lin, Shandong University Xianfeng Yang, University of Maryland, College Park Zhijie (Sasha) Dong, Texas State University Jianping Xing, Shandong University
Show Abstract
With the increasing of transit vehicles in urban
networks, the traditional active transit signal priority control may fall short
of efficiency due to the negative impact to non-priority approaches. In responds
to the control need under such condition, this study presents an integrated
signal progression model, named INTEBAND, to coordinate the platoon of passenger
cars and bus vehicles along the arterial. The INTEBAND model integrates existing
MULTIBAND and BUSBAND with the capability to balance the benefits of passenger
car users and bus passengers. Taking Jinshi road in the city of Jinan, China as
an example, VISSIM simulation modal is employed as an unbiased tool for model
evaluations. Our further exploration with simulation experiments for sensitivity
analysis has also found that INTEBAND will significantly reduce bus passenger
delay and average person delay compared with conventional band controls if the
ratio of bus passengers and passenger-car users exceeds the threshold of 1.5.
Moreover, a multi-classifier model based on simulation results of 477 scenarios
is to answer what conditions is suitable to apply INTEBAND
control.
|
16-4671
|
Experimental Study of Multiplier Effects Created by Providing Transit Signal Priority at Multiple Intersections
Long Truong, La Trobe University Majid Sarvi, University of Melbourne Graham Currie, Monash University
Show Abstract
Transit signal priority (TSP) has proven to be a
cost-effective solution for public transport (PT) vehicles at signalised
intersections. Various studies have focused on the design and operation of TSP,
while few have considered the optimum combination of TSP at an arterial and a
network level. However, it is unclear whether the combination of TSP on an
arterial or a network creates a multiplier effect on PT benefits, i.e. benefits
from providing TSP at multiple intersections are higher than the sum of benefits
from providing TSP at each of those individual intersections. If a multiplier
effect exists, it suggests considerable impacts of TSP on a network-wide
scale.
This paper investigates effects of TSP combinations on arterials to establish if
a multiplier effect exists. All possible spatial combinations of TSP at five
intersections along an arterial are examined with various traffic demand and bus
headway levels and offset settings, i.e. free-flow offsets and optimised offsets
that minimise bus delay.
Regression results show a non-linear relationship between the number of
intersections with TSP and bus delay savings with optimised offsets and specific
bus headways, indicating that providing TSP at multiple intersections can create
a multiplier effect on bus delay savings. With free-flow offsets, the effect of
TSP combinations on bus delay savings is linear. Results also suggest a linear
effect of TSP combinations and a non-linear effect of traffic volume on the
increase in side street traffic delay.
Policy implications and areas for future research are
suggested.
|
16-0465
|
Multimodal Intelligent Transportation Signal System Impact Assessment: Field Testing and Simulation Results
Kyoungho Ahn, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Hesham Rakha, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Kyungwon Kang, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Govindarajan Vadakpat, Office of the Secretary of Transportation (OST)
Show Abstract
The paper evaluates the potential network-wide impacts
of the Multi-Modal Intelligent Transportation Signal System (MMITSS) based on a
field data analysis utilizing data collected from a MMITSS prototype and a
simulation analysis. The Intelligent Traffic Signal System (I-SIG), Transit
Signal Priority (TSP), Freight Signal Priority (FSP), and TSP/FSP bundle
applications were evaluated. The field data analysis demonstrated that MMITSS
applications effectively improved the travel time and the delay of the equipped
vehicles. In particular, FSP reduced the delay of connected trucks by up to
20.9% and I-SIG reduced travel time variability by up to 56%, compared to the
base case. The simulation study found that I-SIG achieved vehicle delay
reductions of 20.6% and TSP effectively saved travel time for both transit and
passenger vehicles on the corridor where TSP was operated; but occasionally
increased the system-wide delay, due to reduced green times on the side streets.
FSP simulation results indicated that FSP successfully reduced travel times by
up to 20.5% for connected trucks. However, the FSP application also increased
system-wide delay, due to increased delays on side streets. The simulation study
found that the TSP/FSP bundle application was effective in assigning priority to
trucks based on a pre-defined hierarchy of control. The study concludes that the
MMITSS I-SIG, TSP, FSP, and TSP/FSP bundle applications improve vehicle travel
time, delay, and travel time reliability for equipped passenger cars, trucks,
and transit vehicles on the test facility, but may produce overall system-wide
negative impacts.
|
16-0731
|
Connected-Vehicle-Based Traffic Signal Control Strategy for Emergency Vehicle Preemption
Hamed Noori, University of Waterloo Liping Fu, University of Waterloo Sajad Shiravi, University of Waterloo
Show Abstract
Connected Vehicle (CV) technologies such as Vehicle to
Vehicle (V2V) and Vehicle to Infrastructure (V2I) promise major benefits in both
mobility and safety applications. One of the CV applications is connected
traffic signal preemption for emergency vehicles enabling the rapid movement of
emergency vehicles in urban arterials. This paper describes an innovative signal
control strategy proposed to decrease Emergency Vehicle Response Time (EVRT). By
employing V2I communication and IEEE 802.11p beaconing concept as well as the
predicted queue length, traffic signals are adjusted adaptively to provide an
early green at the right time so that the queue at the downstream intersections
can be served just in time for the arrival of an emergency vehicle. The
strategy is implemented in the microscopic traffic simulator, SUMO and evaluated
using the City of Toronto network. In addition, a Python-based program is
developed to link the control strategy to SUMO for simulating the traffic with
intelligent traffic signals. The simulation results show a significant reduction
in EVRT using the proposed method.
|
16-6763
|
Convex Quadratic Program Model to Optimize Vehicle and Pedestrian Signals for Isolated Intersections
Chunhui Yu, Tongji University Wanjing Ma, Tongji University Xiaoguang Yang, Tongji University
Show Abstract
The optimization of vehicle and pedestrian signals for
an isolated intersection is a fundamental problem to improve transportation
system efficiency. This paper presents a convex quadratic program model to
optimize traffic signals for an isolated intersection with one- and two-stage
crosswalks under undersaturated traffic. Both vehicle and pedestrian delays are
considered in the optimization objective. The total delay is modeled by use of a
convex quadratic formula. The number of waiting pedestrians on the refuge island
at a two-stage crosswalk is modeled by use of a linear formula so that all
constraints are in linear forms. The convex quadratic grogram model can be
solved by many existing algorithms or softwares efficiently. The proposed model
has three distinguishing features: (
a) the
benefits of both vehicles and pedestrians are considered in a unified framework,
(
b) the number of waiting pedestrians on the
refuge island at a two-stage crosswalk is modeled in a linear form, and (
c) the proposed signal optimization model is a convex
quadratic model that can be easily implemented in practice. The results of the
case study showed that the proposed model would help traffic practitioners,
researchers, and authorities optimize vehicle and pedestrian signals for an
isolated intersection. The consideration of crossing pedestrians has an impact
on the optimal signal cycle.
|
16-5265
|
Effect of Transit Preferential Treatments on Vehicle Travel Time
Zachary Bugg, Kittelson & Associates, Inc. Jon Crisafi, Kittelson & Associates, Inc. Eric Lindstrom, Kittelson & Associates, Inc. Paul Ryus, Kittelson & Associates, Inc.
Show Abstract
Many agencies around the U.S. are implementing transit
preferential treatments, including transit signal priority (TSP), queue jumps,
and queue bypass lanes, for transit vehicles operating in mixed traffic on
arterials (e.g. bus or streetcar). However, the benefits and disadvantages of
these treatments have not yet been quantified using a comprehensive corridor
travel time analysis. This paper includes a VISSIM study of an existing transit
corridor in Fort Lauderdale, Florida and generalizes the results for application
to other sites. The assumptions of the study included average transit headways
of five minutes, a 100-second signal cycle length, and that transit vehicles
would always call for priority (either red truncation or green extension) at
intersections with TSP. Each treatment was tested using volume-to-capacity
ratios of 0.5, 0.8, and 1.0, and the performance measures included transit
vehicle travel time, travel time for all approaching vehicles, and total
intersection delay for all vehicles.
The results indicate that transit stop location,
volume-to-capacity ratio, and type of treatment each have a significant effect
on all three performance measures tested. Some of the principal findings are: a
far side transit stop can reduce transit vehicle travel time by up to five
percent over a near side stop, installing TSP in one direction tends to provide
less negative effects to side street traffic than if TSP is installed in both
directions, and TSP is most effective along a corridor if it is implemented only
at moderately-congested intersections (i.e. those with a v/c ratio between 0.6
and 0.9).
|
16-1724
|
Evaluating Transit Signal Priority and Offset Optimization Strategies in Microsimulation Using Purdue Coordination Diagram
Soheil Sajjadi, Arcadis US Inc Christopher Day, Iowa State University Kyle Bright, Portland State University
Show Abstract
Recent advancements in computer technology have provided
more information to scientists than ever before. There is still a need to
convert all this information into knowledge. Traffic signal controller systems
have been impacted by this revolution as well. A graphical tool called the
Purdue Coordination Diagram (PCD) leverages detailed event-based data to
visualize signal controller operation, offering a new capability to develop
insights about the performance. Analyzing alternative signal controller
operations in the real world condition can be costly, especially for complicated
features such as Transit Signal Priority (TSP) strategies that require
substantial investments to deploy. Therefore, engineers often use
microsimulation models to evaluate the effectiveness of complicated strategies
prior to deployment. This study demonstrates a method to generate PCDs in the
microsimulation level analysis. A computational engine is developed as part of
this study that translates native microsimulation data into the equivalent
event-based data needed to construct the PCDs. The proposed method is applied to
a real world corridor in downtown San Antonio, Texas. The study site consists of
11 intersections, of which seven are signalized. TSP strategies are deployed in
five intersections. Four operational scenarios are considered: No TSP; TSP with
existing offsets; TSP with genetic algorithm optimized offsets; and TSP with
hill climbing optimized offsets. The study demonstrates that the PCD can add
valuable information to an evaluation of this sort. Specifically, the PCDs
generated by the proposed methodology can help the user to evaluate/change TSP
parameters or fine-tune the offset optimization solutions in the microscopic
level.
|
16-6760
|
Transit Signal Priority Control Algorithm with Gaming Theory: Application in Beijing
Wenxin Qiao, World Bank Tong Zhu, Cornell University Xianfeng Yang, University of Maryland, College Park Jun Liu, Beijing Jiaotong University
Show Abstract
Transit Signal Priority (TSP) control, a widely applied
operation strategy that facilitate the movement of transit vehicles through
traffic-signal controlled intersections, has been recognized as one of the most
practical strategies to enhance efficiency and reliability of bus operations.
With the increase on the road user’s value of time, an optimal TSP control is
required not only to guarantee the operational efficiency of buses on priority
approaches but also to reduce the total passengers delay over the entire
intersection. To such need, the developed system shall integrate a function to
wisely allocate the green time between priority phases and non-priority phases.
In this paper, an optimization model is proposed to provide green time
compensation to non-priority phases through a game theory approach. Also to
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model, this study conducts a case
study on a field site in Beijing, China. The experimental results have proved
the performance improvement of the target intersection with the proposed
system.
|
16-5498
|
Multimodal Data Analytics Comparative Visualization Tool: Case Study of Pedestrian Crossing Design
Shayan Khoshmagham, ITERIS, Inc. Larry Head, University of Arizona Mehdi Zamanipour, NRC Research Associateship Yiheng Feng, University of Arizona
Show Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to define a visualization
method to evaluate the performance of a multi-modal traffic signal system.
Previous studies have concentrated on performance assessment for single modes,
such as delay or travel time of passenger vehicles, or transit running times.
The methodology presented in this paper considers an integrated approach to
multi-modal performance assessment. A tool, called a Multi-Modal Performance
Dashboard, is developed to visualize the relationship between various
performance measures and multiple modes. Dashboards can be used to characterize
the performance of an existing system and also to compare before and after
studies when a new design is implemented. Radar diagrams are the basic element
of the Multi-Modal Performance Dashboard tool and are constructed for
performance measures, e.g. passenger vehicle travel time, transit delay,
pedestrian volume, and truck stops, and for each movement at an intersection. An
arterial corridor in the Maricopa County Department of Transportation's
SMARTDrive test bed is analyzed using VISSIM micro-simulation model to study the
effects of different designs and signal timing strategies on several performance
measures for both vehicles and pedestrians. Based on the results of this study,
choosing an appropriate control strategy can impact the different movements of
different modes (including pedestrians) in a variety of ways. The more modes
involved in the system, the more challenging it is to determine the proper
control strategy. Using this comparative tool, alongside statistical models,
makes it easier for decision makers to understand, visualize, and analyze
data.
|
16-5670
|
Characterizing Emergency Vehicle Preemption Operation Using High-Resolution Traffic Signal Event Data
Chih-Sheng Chou, Intelligent Automation, Inc. Andrew Nichols, Virginia Department of Transportation
Show Abstract
This paper proposes the use of a signal phase spectrum
(SPS) plot to analyze high resolution traffic signal event data.
Specifically, the controller performance related to emergency vehicle preemption
operation is characterized in an effort to identify performance measures that
will allow a traffic engineer to better understand the impact that various
configurations have on intersection operations. Performance measures for
individual intersections in coordinated systems including preemption duration,
transition duration, and total interruption time. Performance measures for
networks are based on an emergency vehicle re-identification process for
deriving an emergency vehicle’s trajectory through a network, and the results
can further be used to estimate travel time, travel speed, and
origin-destination. These performance measures are illustrated using a
simulated signal system in Morgantown, WV. Transition modes are varied in
the simulation network to determine the relative performance measures.
Case studies are presented for using high resolution data to troubleshoot field
preemption operation using the Morgantown, WV and Huntington, WV signal
systems.
|
16-2316
|
Multimodal Intelligent Transportation Signal System Simulation Model Development and Assessment
Kyoungho Ahn, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Hesham Rakha, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Kyungwon Kang, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Govindarajan Vadakpat, Office of the Secretary of Transportation (OST)
Show Abstract
The study develops the Multi-Modal Intelligent
Transportation Signal System (MMITSS) simulation tool to assess the potential
impacts of a broader MMITSS deployment, which will ultimately facilitate the
site-independent analysis of MMITSS applications. The study also evaluates the
effectiveness of the MMITSS application to identify the most beneficial
operational conditions for each MMITSS operational scenario considering a
combination of simulation variables and traffic demand levels. The MMITSS
simulation platform consists of the VISSIM microscopic traffic simulation
software, the Basic Safety Message (BSM) distributor program, the Econolite
ASC/3 traffic controller emulator that runs on a Windows platform and a Road
Side Equipment (RSE) Module that runs on a Linux platform. The tool is then used
to conduct a simulation study of the Intelligent Traffic Signal System (I-SIG).
The study demonstrates that I-SIG reduces vehicle delay by up to 35% and
increases average traffic stream speed by up to 27%. In addition, Transit Signal
Priority (TSP) is demonstrated to reduce travel time for both transit and
passenger vehicles on the corridor by up to 29% and 28%, respectively. However,
the TSP can increase system-wide delay because it reduces green times on the
side streets. The study also demonstrates that Freight Signal Priority (FSP) can
be effectively utilized along major freight routes. While the FSP significantly
reduces truck delay, network-wide delay is increased substantially, especially
in the high truck composition scenario. The TSP/FSP bundle simulation study
demonstrates that the bundle operation successfully executed a hierarchical
level of priority providing higher priority for trucks. The study concludes that
overall MMITSS applications effectively improve vehicle travel time and delay
for equipped and potentially non-equipped vehicles depending on the scenarios
considered. Typically system-wide dis-benefits are observed when TSP, FSP, and
TSP/FSP types of control are applied.
|
16-1141
|